Breeders' Cup Turf: Handicapping Post Mortem

Welcome Friends to The Turk Blog, where I write about mostly older horses running routes over grass, and from that I assemble exacta bets.  I've been a handicapper since the mid 1980's and a horse racing blogger since 2008.  

I didn't think Ethical Diamond had a chance.  

Nothing here screams it:  a Maiden at start of 5 YO campaign.  His jockey jumped to 2X Turf Winner Rebel's Romance.  

Nothing here screams winner:  Most of his $521K in earnings from 2025 after a brutal 2024 (someone believed in him!). The race chart implies pressing and not deep closer.  Only 1/5 of his earnings from this distance.  

Breeders' Cup Turf G1: 1 1/2 Miles for 3 YO and Up

14 September 2025;  Curragh; Irish Leger G1; 

Amiloc (GB) Place finish for 3 YO gelding.  6 of 6 Lifetime Exacta

27 September 2025; Aqueduct; Turf Classic G1;

El Cordobes (Ire) (Show 3 3/4 back), Rebel Red (GB) (5th 7 3/4 back), Rebel's Romance (Ire) (Win 3 1/2 in front ), Redistricting (GB) (Place 3 1/2 back)

23 August 2025; York (GB); Ebor Handicap Stakes  Class 2; 

Ethical Diamond (Ire) (Win by 2 1/2)

27 September 2025; Santa Anita; John Henry Turf Championship G1; 

Gold Phoenix (Ire) (Win by 1 1/4 in front) 

7 September 2025; Baden-Baden (Ger); Grosser Preis von Baden G1;

Goliath (Ger) (Win by 1 1/4 lengths)

4 October 2025; Aqueduct; Jockey Club Derby Invitational G2;

Hill Road (Show 2 1/2 lengths back)

5 October 2025; Longchamp (Fr); Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe G1; 

Minnie Hauk (Ire) (Place by a head)

4 October 2025; Longchamp (Fr); Prix Dollar G2; 

Rashabar (Ire) (4th- 4 lengths back- (French Only Video-Green, Blue Sleeves, Green Dots on White #9 horse)

4 October 2025; Woodbine; Canadian International G1; 

Silawi (Ire) (Win by a nose), Tawny Port (Place by a nose)

30 August 2025; Kentucky Downs; Nashville Derby G3

Wimbledon Hawkeye (GB) (Win by a head), Hill Road (Show 3 3/4 lengths back)

The Breeders Cup Turf   G1:  1 1/2 Miles on the Del Mar Turf Course, for 3 YOs and Up

What I said Prerace:

I was going to call this an interesting field, and then I thought about it, and if you removed Minnie Hauk (Ire) and Rebel's Romance (Ire) from the field, then it would be a very interesting American Grade 1 turf race.  Including them makes this a top heavy race with a fairly mediocre bottom of the field, especially at the outside posts.  The filly, Minnie Hauk (Ire), as morning line favorite at 8-5 I didn't think was appropriate.  Yes she carries 7 less pounds than Rebel's Romance but it's her 8th start, the furthest she's traveled before coming to Del Mar was Ireland to France,  a flight too short to pass out complimentary beverages. At 3 YO, if this filly wins it will be shocking and historic.  Yes she can, I don't think it will happen.  But it's not exactly like Rebel's Romance winning will provide value. The two of them combined for 51.5% of the adjusted Morning Line and 53.6% of Turk's Fair Odds.  I think we will have to get creative with the Betting Structure to realize value.

1.  Have Rebel's Romance (Ire) or Minnie Hauk (Ire) first with a few logical late runners in Place.

2. Swing for the Fence:  Put a bunch of Horses (my non-RED) in Win Spot and put both Minnie Hauk and Rebel's Romance in Place Spot.  

 I priced out both at $24 Dollar Options:

$2 Exacta:  1-8 OVER 2-10-4-3-9-6 for $24

OR

$2 Exacta 2-10-4-3-9-6 OVER 1-8

I'm not wasting money on the most logical, a 1-8 Boxed finish.  

Exacta History for 2024-2025

Tomlinson Analysis for Turf and Distance:

The Race Replay

 

Ethical Diamond's run in the visualization below is just as impressive as what my eyes saw.  Paying $282 on a $2 exacta with 2-1 Rebel's Romance, it showed the strategy I had of putting the favorites in Place and a bunch of long shots in Win Spot was sound, I just picked the wrong long shot.  Honestly, I didn't see this coming and sometimes you can complete the post mortem and come away with no other lesson except you can't win them all!

Have Fun Friends, Turk Out!